Sense of powerlessness leads to political insanity in America
Rioters in the Capitol on Jan. 6
The most compelling political statements today are those that focus on mutual respect and factual truth — such as this statement<https://simplifygov.us13.list-manage.com/track/click?u=9df171ae6d6b7a01570236616&id=74cae9b3ca&e=f8aee0dd0d by Republican Mayor David Holt, of Oklahoma City, just two days before the mob attacked the Capitol, or the victory statement https://simplifygov.us13.list-manage.com/track/click?u=9df171ae6d6b7a01570236616&id=e43c382fe9&e=f8aee0dd0d>t<https://simplifygov.us13.list-manage.com/track/click?u=9df171ae6d6b7a01570236616&id=e4f09d32e3&e=f8aee0dd0d by Georgia Democratic Sen.-elect Raphael Warnock.
But why does such a large group of Americans feel so alienated that they abandon basic civilized values? One of the main reasons, I think, is a sense of powerlessness. They're stretched thin, due to economic forces beyond their control. They don't think that their views matter, or that they can make a difference in, say, their schools or communities. They can't even be themselves. Spontaneity, which philosopher Hannah Arendt considered "the most elementary manifestation of human freedom," is fraught with legal peril: "Can I prove what I'm about to say or do is legally correct?"
The cure requires reviving human responsibility at all levels of authority. People need to feel free to roll up their sleeves and get things done. They need to feel free to be themselves in daily interactions, accountable for their overall character and competence. A functioning democracy requires officials to take responsibility for results, not mindless compliance. In an essay published this week by Yale Law Journal, "From Progressivism to Paralysis’’ https://simplifygov.us13.list-manage.com/track/click?u=9df171ae6d6b7a01570236616&id=9b9303c0e3&e=f8aee0dd0d>," I describe how good government slowly evolved into a framework that disempowers everyone, even the president, from acting sensibly.
The sluggish rollout of COVID-19 vaccines is only the latest manifestation of a micromanagement governing philosophy that suffocates leadership as well as disempowering citizens.
It's time to reboot the system, not to deregulate but re-regulate in a way that revives the American can-do spirit at all levels of society. This requires a new movement. If you agree, please contact phoward@commongood.org.
Philip K. Howard, a New York-based lawyer, civic and cultural leader, legal and regulatory reformer and photographer, is founder and chairman of Common Good (commongood.org). He’s the author of The Death of Common Sense, The Collapse of the Common Good, Life Without Lawyers, The Rule of Nobody and Try Common Sense.